Quoting Michael Loo to Jim Weller <=-
... The innumerable bottled sauces are enemies of good cookery.
Partly true, but Worcestershire, HP, and others have been
assimilated into even good cooking over the years.
JIM WELLER wrote to MICHAEL LOO <=-
And Heinz has totally destroyed HP. It is less tangy and much
sweeter (and now has HFCS in it). As well they have made a whole
bunch of stupid new versions in an effort to increase sales. I now
buy my own malt vinegar and get some tamarind paste from my Asian
store and reverse engineer my own.
This version lacks tamarind ...
MMMMM----- Recipe via Meal-Master (tm) v8.06
Title: Sydney Oland's HP Sauce
Categories: Condiments, Copycat
Yield: 1 quart
Quoting Dave Drum to Jim Weller <=-
Heinz has totally destroyed HP.
I now buy my own malt vinegar and get some tamarind paste
This version lacks tamarind ...
Title: Sydney Oland's HP Sauce
from Jamie Oliver's website. It also lacks tamarind .... so,
it's your kitchen - add some if you wish.
JIM WELLER wrote to DAVE DRUM <=-
Heinz has totally destroyed HP.
I now buy my own malt vinegar and get some tamarind paste
This version lacks tamarind ...
Title: Sydney Oland's HP Sauce
from Jamie Oliver's website. It also lacks tamarind .... so,
it's your kitchen - add some if you wish.
It is a predominant flavour in the original formula and I consider it essential to the mix.
Quoting Dave Drum to Jim Weller <=-
A1 may be a variant on HP.
I've never (afaik) had HP.
Country Bob
I don't put sauces like that on my steaks.
Still A1 works on hamburgers for me.
JIM WELLER wrote to DAVE DRUM <=-
A1 may be a variant on HP.
Only in the broadest sense that they are both brown so called steak sauces.
I've never (afaik) had HP.
HP Sauce has a tomato base, various spices, lots of malt vinegar and molasses, and is flavoured with prunes and tamarind.
A-1 Sauce has a tomato base with spices too, but uses white vinegar
and caramel flavoured with raisins and oranges.
Country Bob
I hadn't heard of it so I googled it. It seems to be local to
Illinois and it sounds pretty sweet as it has four kinds of sugar
in it!
I don't put sauces like that on my steaks.
Neither do I but they are great on other things like sausages,
meatloaf and egg dishes.
Still A1 works on hamburgers for me.
And of course burgers.
I add vinegar or lemon juice plus some hot sauce to most of them to
bend them to my tastes, just as I do with commercial BBQ sauces.
Dave Drum wrote to JIM WELLER <=-
Still A1 works on hamburgers for me. Bv)=
Sean Dennis wrote to Dave Drum <=-
Still A1 works on hamburgers for me. Bv)=
I love A1 on hambrugers. I do put some on the side when I have a steak but that's because I'm dentally challenged and the A1 "lubricates" the steak to make it easier for me to process.
A1 is great on a Steak n' Shake/Freddy's steakburger.
Quoting Dave Drum to Jim Weller <=-
Heinz has totally destroyed HP.
there's a major boycott going on by patriotic Britishers
I wonder that some enterprising Brit has not reverse engineered
the original HP sauce and begun marketing it
Title: Homemade HP Sauce
1 tb Tomato paste
1 tb Dark treacle
375 ml Apple cider vinegar
375 ml Brown sugar
JIM WELLER wrote to DAVE DRUM <=-
Heinz has totally destroyed HP.
there's a major boycott going on by patriotic Britishers
I wonder that some enterprising Brit has not reverse engineered
the original HP sauce and begun marketing it
It seems like a brilliant idea.
Title: Homemade HP Sauce
1 tb Tomato paste
1 tb Dark treacle
375 ml Apple cider vinegar
375 ml Brown sugar
I'd suggest that equal quantities of tomato paste, water, malt
vinegar and treacle as a base would be closer to the real thing
although this recipe would still make a nice fruity, fairly sweet
sauce.
Quoting Dave Drum to Jim Weller <=-
reverse engineered ...
It would help if someone had the "real" recipe from
back-in-the-day.
JIM WELLER wrote to DAVE DRUM <=-
reverse engineered ...
It would help if someone had the "real" recipe from
back-in-the-day.
The original recipe was a trade secret of the originator that was
passed on to subsequent owners. But the ingredients listed on the
label (and their order) on the bottles of the British product before Kraft-Heinz took over gives us a fair idea of how to reproduce
something very like it.
Sysop: | sneaky |
---|---|
Location: | Ashburton,NZ |
Users: | 2 |
Nodes: | 8 (0 / 8) |
Uptime: | 41:12:21 |
Calls: | 2,117 |
Calls today: | 1 |
Files: | 11,149 |
D/L today: |
315 files (11,412K bytes) |
Messages: | 952,755 |